[{"data":1,"prerenderedAt":514},["ShallowReactive",2],{"site-schema":3,"article-en-staffing-vs-onsite-vs-outsourcing-vs-fdt":106,"article-related-en-staffing-vs-onsite-vs-outsourcing-vs-fdt":500},{"@context":4,"@graph":5},"https:\u002F\u002Fschema.org",[6,85,97],{"@type":7,"@id":8,"name":9,"alternateName":10,"description":17,"knowsAbout":18,"legalName":27,"foundingDate":28,"numberOfEmployees":29,"taxID":30,"url":31,"logo":32,"founder":33,"contactPoint":35,"address":49,"location":55,"sameAs":75},"Organization","https:\u002F\u002Fjoinx.co\u002F#organization","JoinX哲煜科技",[11,12,13,14,15,16],"JoinX","TWJOIN","哲煜科技","哲煜科技股份有限公司","TWJOIN 哲煜科技","twjoin.com","JoinX 哲煜科技（原品牌名 TWJOIN）是 2016 年在台北成立的軟體開發公司，80+ 人自有團隊，承接客製系統、APP、AI 導入與 IoT 開發，以及軟體外包與既有系統接手維運，服務 220+ 客戶、完成 520+ 專案。",[19,20,21,22,23,24,25,26],"軟體外包","客製化系統開發","APP 開發","AI 導入","AI Agent 開發","IoT APP 開發","ERP 系統整合","既有系統接手維運","JoinX Co., Ltd.","2016-04-28",80,"43774383","https:\u002F\u002Fjoinx.co","https:\u002F\u002Fjoinx.co\u002Fimages\u002Flogo-with-name.png",{"@id":34},"https:\u002F\u002Fjoinx.co\u002F#person-jack-lee",[36],{"@type":37,"contactType":38,"url":39,"telephone":40,"email":41,"areaServed":42,"availableLanguage":45},"ContactPoint","customer service","https:\u002F\u002Fjoinx.co\u002Fcontact-us","+886-2-8771-9095","service@joinx.co",[43,44],"TW","JP",[46,47,48],"zh-Hant","en","ja",{"@type":50,"streetAddress":51,"postalCode":52,"addressLocality":53,"addressRegion":54,"addressCountry":43},"PostalAddress","民生東路二段170號8樓","104","台北市中山區","台灣",[56,63,69],{"@type":57,"name":58,"address":59},"Place","JoinX 台中辦公室",{"@type":50,"streetAddress":60,"postalCode":61,"addressLocality":62,"addressRegion":54,"addressCountry":43},"台灣大道二段360號21樓C室","40453","台中市北區",{"@type":57,"name":64,"address":65},"JoinX 高雄辦公室",{"@type":50,"streetAddress":66,"postalCode":67,"addressLocality":68,"addressRegion":54,"addressCountry":43},"民族一路80號2樓之一","807","高雄市三民區",{"@type":57,"name":70,"address":71},"JoinX 東京辦公室",{"@type":50,"streetAddress":72,"postalCode":73,"addressLocality":74,"addressCountry":44},"東五反田5-22-37 Office Circle N 五反田 9樓","141-0022","東京都品川區",[76,77,78,79,80,81,82,83,84],"https:\u002F\u002Fwww.crunchbase.com\u002Forganization\u002Ftwjoin","https:\u002F\u002Fwww.facebook.com\u002FJoinX.TW","https:\u002F\u002Ftw.linkedin.com\u002Fcompany\u002F%E5%93%B2%E7%85%9C%E7%A7%91%E6%8A%80","https:\u002F\u002Fwww.youtube.com\u002Fc\u002Fjoinstuido%E5%93%B2%E7%85%9C%E7%A7%91%E6%8A%80","https:\u002F\u002Fmedium.com\u002Ftwjoin","https:\u002F\u002Fwww.104.com.tw\u002Fcompany\u002F1a2x6bjomb","https:\u002F\u002Fclutch.co\u002Fprofile\u002Fjoinx","https:\u002F\u002Fwww.goodfirms.co\u002Fcompany\u002Ftwjoin","https:\u002F\u002Ftwjoin.com",{"@type":86,"@id":34,"name":87,"alternateName":88,"jobTitle":89,"worksFor":90,"url":91,"sameAs":92},"Person","李秉哲","Jack Lee","創辦人暨執行長",{"@id":8},"https:\u002F\u002Fjack88.joinx.co\u002F",[93,94,95,96],"https:\u002F\u002Fwww.instagram.com\u002Fjack88.podcast\u002F","https:\u002F\u002Fwww.threads.net\u002F@jack88.podcast","https:\u002F\u002Fjoinx.co\u002Fjack88\u002F","https:\u002F\u002Fwww.linkedin.com\u002Fin\u002Fjacklee-taiwan\u002F",{"@type":98,"@id":99,"url":31,"name":9,"alternateName":100,"publisher":101,"inLanguage":102},"WebSite","https:\u002F\u002Fjoinx.co\u002F#website",[11,13,9],{"@id":8},[103,104,105],"zh-Hant-TW","en-US","ja-JP",{"id":107,"title":108,"body":109,"category":469,"cover":470,"dateModified":471,"description":472,"extension":473,"faq":471,"hasCoverTitle":474,"locale":47,"meta":475,"navigation":476,"need":477,"path":478,"seo":479,"seoDescription":471,"seoTitle":471,"sources":480,"stem":490,"takeaways":491,"time":497,"type":498,"__hash__":499},"content\u002Fen\u002Farticle\u002Fstaffing-vs-onsite-vs-outsourcing-vs-fdt.md","Staff Augmentation, Onsite Engineers, Software Outsourcing or an FDT? Who Owns the Result and How Each Is Priced",{"type":110,"value":111,"toc":451},"minimark",[112,120,125,128,156,165,169,172,298,301,305,308,311,314,318,321,324,332,335,339,342,345,348,375,379,382,385,388,411,415,420,423,427,430,434,437,441,444,448],[113,114,115,119],"p",{},[116,117,118],"strong",{},"Staff augmentation and onsite engineers buy engineering time: the company directs the work and owns the result. Software outsourcing and an FDT buy outcomes, and the vendor is responsible for delivery."," No model is better in every case; the difference lies in whether someone inside the company can lead engineers, how clear the requirements are, and where knowledge should stay once the work is done.",[121,122,124],"h2",{"id":123},"what-are-staff-augmentation-onsite-engineers-software-outsourcing-and-an-fdt","What are staff augmentation, onsite engineers, software outsourcing and an FDT?",[113,126,127],{},"All four bring outside people in to build software, but each buys something different: staff augmentation buys people, onsite engineering buys engineers' time in your office, software outsourcing buys a system built to spec, and an FDT buys the whole outcome from finding the use case to launch.",[129,130,131,138,144,150],"ul",{},[132,133,134,137],"li",{},[116,135,136],{},"Staff augmentation (dispatched labor)",": a staffing agency employs engineers and sends them to work at the company, which directs their daily work. Under Taiwan's Labor Standards Act, the agency is the dispatched worker's employer, and the client may not interview or designate specific workers before dispatch.",[132,139,140,143],{},[116,141,142],{},"Onsite engineers",": a vendor's engineers work in the company's office, usually billed by person-month, with tasks assigned by the company's managers. In practice this often overlaps with dispatch; the difference is whether the contract is labor dispatch or an outsourced service.",[132,145,146,149],{},[116,147,148],{},"Software outsourcing",": the company commissions a vendor to develop a system, and the vendor delivers to spec. Under Taiwan's Civil Code this is a contract for work: payment is due once the agreed work is completed.",[132,151,152,155],{},[116,153,154],{},"FDT (forward deployed team)",": a team of a PM, designer, front-end, back-end and AI engineers works inside the company's processes to find use cases, build prototypes, and then take them to production and maintain them, with each stage accepted on results.",[113,157,158,159,164],{},"For how an FDT differs from an FDE or an AI consultant, see ",[160,161,163],"a",{"href":162},"\u002Fen\u002Farticle\u002Fforward-deployed-engineer-fde-fdt\u002F","What is an FDE","; this article focuses on comparing it with staff augmentation and onsite engineers.",[121,166,168],{"id":167},"how-do-the-four-models-differ","How do the four models differ?",[113,170,171],{},"The biggest difference is who owns the result. With staff augmentation and onsite engineers, the company directs the work and owns the result; with software outsourcing and an FDT, the vendor is responsible for delivery. Pricing, knowledge retention and management cost all follow from this.",[173,174,175,195],"table",{},[176,177,178],"thead",{},[179,180,181,185,188,190,192],"tr",{},[182,183,184],"th",{},"Comparison",[182,186,187],{},"Staff augmentation",[182,189,142],{},[182,191,148],{},[182,193,194],{},"FDT",[196,197,198,216,232,248,264,281],"tbody",{},[179,199,200,204,207,210,213],{},[201,202,203],"td",{},"Who directs the work",[201,205,206],{},"The company",[201,208,209],{},"The company's managers; the vendor supplies people",[201,211,212],{},"The vendor, according to the spec",[201,214,215],{},"The vendor's PM, setting use cases with the company's contact",[179,217,218,221,223,226,229],{},[201,219,220],{},"Who owns the result",[201,222,206],{},[201,224,225],{},"The company; the vendor ensures staffing",[201,227,228],{},"The vendor delivers to spec",[201,230,231],{},"The vendor delivers against stage thresholds",[179,233,234,237,240,242,245],{},[201,235,236],{},"How it is priced",[201,238,239],{},"Per person-month or hour",[201,241,239],{},[201,243,244],{},"Fixed price or in stages",[201,246,247],{},"In stages, each accepted on results",[179,249,250,253,256,258,261],{},[201,251,252],{},"How source code and knowledge are retained",[201,254,255],{},"Code stays with the company, knowledge stays with people",[201,257,255],{},[201,259,260],{},"Source code and documents delivered under the contract",[201,262,263],{},"Source code, specifications and test documents are deliverables",[179,265,266,269,272,275,278],{},[201,267,268],{},"Management cost for the company",[201,270,271],{},"High: someone must assign work and review code",[201,273,274],{},"High: as with staff augmentation, plus attendance and desk space",[201,276,277],{},"Medium: writing specs and acceptance",[201,279,280],{},"Medium: a contact joins use case discovery and acceptance",[179,282,283,286,289,292,295],{},[201,284,285],{},"Impact of staff turnover",[201,287,288],{},"Large: find someone new and hand over again",[201,290,291],{},"Large: handover gaps are common",[201,293,294],{},"Small: the vendor covers internally",[201,296,297],{},"Small: the same team continues",[113,299,300],{},"This table does not say one model is better. If you already have a PM and technical lead and only lack hands, staff augmentation or onsite engineers are the most direct; if requirements are clear and you want the vendor to own the result, software outsourcing is simpler; if the use case still needs to be found and the result will be used long term, an FDT fits better.",[121,302,304],{"id":303},"who-owns-the-result-and-why-does-it-matter-most","Who owns the result, and why does it matter most?",[113,306,307],{},"Because it decides whom you turn to when something goes wrong. With staff augmentation and onsite engineers, a system that fails or is built wrong is a matter of the company's own management; with outsourcing and an FDT, the vendor must deliver against the contract or acceptance thresholds and fix the work until it meets them.",[113,309,310],{},"The law draws the same line. Dispatch is a labor relationship in which the client directs the worker, and Article 63-1 of the Labor Standards Act makes the client and the agency jointly liable for occupational accident compensation of dispatched workers, so the company takes on part of an employer's duties. Software outsourcing is usually a contract for work under Article 490 of the Civil Code: the contractor completes the agreed work, and the client pays once it is done.",[113,312,313],{},"The most common problem in practice is a contract called outsourcing that is managed like dispatch: the company's managers direct the vendor's engineers every day, the spec changes at will, and when the delivery falls short, nobody can say whose responsibility it is. Deciding who directs and who owns the result before you start matters more than which vendor you pick.",[121,315,317],{"id":316},"how-is-each-priced-and-which-costs-less","How is each priced, and which costs less?",[113,319,320],{},"Staff augmentation and onsite engineers are billed by person-month or hour, so you pay for time while managing output yourself; software outsourcing is usually a fixed price or staged; an FDT is priced in stages, with each stage accepted on results before you decide whether to fund the next.",[113,322,323],{},"Which costs less depends on whether the company can manage engineers well. With experienced technical leads in-house, the unit cost of staff augmentation or onsite engineers can be lower; without them, the time spent on communication, rework and handover often costs more than the person-month rate on paper.",[113,325,326,327,331],{},"As an example of staged FDT pricing, JoinX's AI implementation team charges about NT$300,000 to 800,000 for a PoC, NT$500,000 to 1.2 million for an MVP, and NT$800,000 to 2.5 million for a production launch, with cross-department and multi-system work quoted by scope; AI model API and cloud costs are billed separately by usage. See ",[160,328,330],{"href":329},"\u002Fen\u002Fai-implementation-team\u002F","AI implementation team"," for details.",[333,334],"article-cta",{},[121,336,338],{"id":337},"how-are-source-code-and-knowledge-retained","How are source code and knowledge retained?",[113,340,341],{},"Source code depends on the contract, and knowledge depends on documentation. Code written by dispatched or onsite engineers usually sits in the company's environment, but why the system was designed that way mostly lives in the engineers' heads and leaves with them. Outsourcing and FDT engagements must include source code, specifications and test documents in the deliverables.",[113,343,344],{},"Under Article 12 of Taiwan's Copyright Act, when a work is commissioned and ownership is not agreed, the economic rights belong to the party who created it, and the commissioning party may only use it. So whatever the model, code ownership must be written into the contract.",[113,346,347],{},"For knowledge to stay, the deliverables should include at least:",[349,350,351,357,363,369],"ol",{},[132,352,353,356],{},[116,354,355],{},"Source code and deployment",": kept in version control the company can access, with deployment and environment setup instructions.",[132,358,359,362],{},[116,360,361],{},"Specifications",": functional specs, workflows and exceptions that explain why the system was designed the way it is.",[132,364,365,368],{},[116,366,367],{},"Tests",": automated tests and test cases, so whoever takes over can tell whether a change breaks something.",[132,370,371,374],{},[116,372,373],{},"Handover and training",": operating and maintenance instructions included in acceptance, not passed on verbally.",[121,376,378],{"id":377},"how-does-joinx-work-with-clients","How does JoinX work with clients?",[113,380,381],{},"JoinX's members are all our own full-time employees. We do not provide staff augmentation or onsite placements; we take responsibility for delivery through software outsourcing and FDT engagements, and when needed we visit clients' offices regularly for meetings to confirm requirements and discuss approaches directly with frontline staff.",[113,383,384],{},"Not being onsite does not mean not understanding the floor. Interviews, process observation and testing take place at the client's site, while day-to-day development is done in-house by the same team, so the division of work among PM, designers and engineers and code review are not broken up by people being scattered across locations.",[113,386,387],{},"We use spec-driven development (SDD) to write down workflows and exceptions, and test-driven development (TDD) to make sure each release does not break existing features; source code and documents are delivered together, and handover and training are part of acceptance. Real long-term engagements:",[129,389,390,401],{},[132,391,392,395,396,400],{},[116,393,394],{},"驊曖體育",": we began working on its yoga studio management system in 2020 and have released versions up to the ninth, with the same team maintaining it after launch. See the ",[160,397,399],{"href":398},"\u002Fen\u002Fcase-studies\u002Fwhayoga\u002F","驊曖體育 case study",".",[132,402,403,406,407,400],{},[116,404,405],{},"Capital Investment Trust",": JoinX is an IT outsourcing developer that meets the FSC's standards, and maintains Capital Investment Trust's website, ETF site and app. See the ",[160,408,410],{"href":409},"\u002Fen\u002Fcase-studies\u002Fcapital\u002F","Capital Investment Trust case study",[121,412,414],{"id":413},"frequently-asked-questions","Frequently Asked Questions",[416,417,419],"h3",{"id":418},"what-is-the-difference-between-an-onsite-engineer-and-an-outsourced-engineer","What is the difference between an onsite engineer and an outsourced engineer?",[113,421,422],{},"The difference is who directs the work and who owns the result. An onsite engineer works in the company's office, takes tasks from the company's managers, and the company owns the result; an outsourced engineer's work is arranged by the vendor, which is responsible for the delivered system against the spec. The two are often confused, so confirm the nature of the contract before signing.",[416,424,426],{"id":425},"can-a-software-project-be-done-with-dispatched-engineers","Can a software project be done with dispatched engineers?",[113,428,429],{},"Yes, provided the company has a PM and technical lead who can lead engineers. Dispatched engineers are directed by the company, so breaking down requirements, reviewing code and controlling quality are all the company's job; without those roles, outsourcing or an FDT is usually more reliable.",[416,431,433],{"id":432},"does-an-fdt-have-to-sit-in-the-clients-office-every-day","Does an FDT have to sit in the client's office every day?",[113,435,436],{},"Not necessarily. What matters for an FDT is that the people building have direct contact with the data and frontline staff; interviews and testing can happen on site, and day-to-day development can happen within the team. JoinX does not work onsite, but we visit clients' offices regularly for meetings to confirm requirements directly.",[416,438,440],{"id":439},"what-happens-to-the-system-when-a-dispatched-or-onsite-engineer-leaves","What happens to the system when a dispatched or onsite engineer leaves?",[113,442,443],{},"It depends on whether documentation and code were kept properly. If the code is in the company's version control and specifications and test documents are complete, a new engineer or vendor can take over; if knowledge lived only with the person who left, the code and architecture usually need to be reviewed before deciding how to maintain them.",[416,445,447],{"id":446},"how-do-we-move-from-onsite-engineers-to-outsourcing-or-an-fdt","How do we move from onsite engineers to outsourcing or an FDT?",[113,449,450],{},"First review the existing system's code, documents and in-progress requirements, and make that handover a stage of its own; then the new team takes over against a spec or stage thresholds. During the transition, old and new people can overlap for a while so knowledge is not lost in the handover.",{"title":452,"searchDepth":453,"depth":453,"links":454},"",2,[455,456,457,458,459,460,461],{"id":123,"depth":453,"text":124},{"id":167,"depth":453,"text":168},{"id":303,"depth":453,"text":304},{"id":316,"depth":453,"text":317},{"id":337,"depth":453,"text":338},{"id":377,"depth":453,"text":378},{"id":413,"depth":453,"text":414,"children":462},[463,465,466,467,468],{"id":418,"depth":464,"text":419},3,{"id":425,"depth":464,"text":426},{"id":432,"depth":464,"text":433},{"id":439,"depth":464,"text":440},{"id":446,"depth":464,"text":447},"Technology Insights","\u002Fimages\u002Fblog\u002Fstaffing-vs-onsite-vs-outsourcing-vs-fdt.webp",null,"Staff augmentation and onsite engineers buy engineering time: the company directs the work and owns the result. Software outsourcing buys a system built to spec, and the vendor is responsible for delivering it. A forward deployed team (FDT) takes a project from finding the use case to launch as one team, priced in stages and accepted on results. This article compares the four models in one table on who owns the result, how each is priced, how source code and knowledge are retained, and how much management the company has to put in, and explains when each fits.","md",false,{},true,"custom software","\u002Fen\u002Farticle\u002Fstaffing-vs-onsite-vs-outsourcing-vs-fdt",{"title":108,"description":472},[481,484,487],{"name":482,"issuer":483},"Labor Standards Act, Articles 17-1 and 63-1 (protection of dispatched workers)","Ministry of Labor, Taiwan",{"name":485,"issuer":486},"Civil Code, Article 490 (contract for work)","Ministry of Justice, Taiwan",{"name":488,"issuer":489},"Copyright Act, Article 12","Intellectual Property Office, Ministry of Economic Affairs, Taiwan","en\u002Farticle\u002Fstaffing-vs-onsite-vs-outsourcing-vs-fdt",[492,493,494,495,496],"Staff augmentation and onsite engineers buy engineering time, so the company directs the work and owns the result; software outsourcing and an FDT buy outcomes, and the vendor is responsible for delivery.","Staff augmentation and onsite engineers are usually billed by person-month or hour, software outsourcing by fixed price or in stages, and an FDT in stages with each stage accepted on results.","With staff augmentation and onsite engineers, knowledge lives in people and is easily lost when they leave; with outsourcing and an FDT, source code, specifications and test documents must be part of the deliverables for knowledge to stay.","If you already have a PM and technical lead and only lack hands, staff augmentation or onsite engineers are the most direct; with a clear spec, choose software outsourcing; if the use case still needs to be found and the result will be used long term, an FDT fits better.","JoinX does not provide staff augmentation or onsite placements, but we visit clients' offices regularly for meetings to confirm requirements directly with frontline staff.","2026\u002F11\u002F04","blog","wpx-pS9u2zV1G58VXeaIB9v7Zyb284iw1Zz3uTDKCV8",[501,506,510],{"slug":502,"title":503,"time":504,"cover":505,"need":477},"financial-system-development-guide","How to Choose a Developer for Outsourced Financial Systems: IT Outsourcing Rules and Vendor Checks for Banks and Investment Trusts","2026\u002F11\u002F06","\u002Fimages\u002Fblog\u002Ffinancial-system-development-guide.webp",{"slug":507,"title":508,"time":497,"cover":509,"need":477},"admin-backoffice-system-development","Admin Back-Office System Development: Modules, Permissions, Costs and Acceptance","\u002Fimages\u002Fblog\u002Fadmin-backoffice-system-development.webp",{"slug":511,"title":512,"time":497,"cover":513,"need":477},"custom-system-development-types-cost-cases","Custom System Development: Who It Suits, Common Types, Costs and Taiwan Case Studies","\u002Fimages\u002Fblog\u002Fcustom-system-development-types-cost-cases.webp",1794558660358]